Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
Research Methods: A Tool for Life


ESP: Science or Pseudoscience?
2
Science and Pseudoscience:
Zener Cards
3
Science or Pseudoscience
  • To demonstrate a typical approach for testing for the presence of ESP, follow the directions provided.


  • For each of the 25 trials, try to predict which Zener figure the sender is trying to communicate.
4
Science and Pseudoscience
5
Zener Stimuli
To Test for ESP
6
Zener Cards
Trials 1-25
7
Science and Pseudoscience
  • You expect to get 5 correct by chance
  • How many correct did you get?
  • Scores between 3 and 7 are said not to reveal any powers of ESP.
  • Scores of 8 or above are said to reveal ESP
  • Scores of 2 or 1 are said to reveal “negative Psi”


  • Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zener_card
8
Science and Pseudoscience
  • Why do you think some people had higher or lower than expected scores?


  • How would you test to see if the person was really telepathic with regard to Zener cards?
9
Science and Pseudoscience
  • Let’s do it again.
10
 
11
 
12
 
13
Science and Pseudoscience
  • Is there any evidence that any of you have ESP?


  • What tended to happen on Trial 2 to a person’s score when he or she had a large number of correct responses on Trial 1?  Why?
14
Science and Pseudoscience
  • What evidence would you need to convince you that a person does or does not have telepathic powers?


  • Could you design an experiment to provide the evidence?
15
Problems in Pseudoscientific Thought
  • Anecdotes do not make a science
  • Scientific language does not make a science
  • Bold statements do not make claims true
  • Heresy does not equal correctness
  • Rumors do not equal reality
  • Unexplained is not inexplicable
  • Coincidence does not equal proof


  • Source: Shermer, M. (1997). Why People Believe Weird Things: Pseudoscience, Superstition, and Other Confusions of Our Time. New York: W. H. Freeman.