Favorite Ithaca Sandwiches

We asked on Facebook and Twitter what your favorite sandwiches were when you were an IC student, and you told us! Unfortunately, Benchwarmers, Ragmanns, and Home Dairy are no longer around. But with Rogan’s proximity to campus, it’s no surprise the Bomber sub was the number one answer.


The Bomber Sub • Rogan's Corner

Made with grilled steak, breaded chicken, cheese, wing sauce, and ranch dressing, the Bomber sub is a South Hill delicacy. Rogan’s also has calzones named after each of IC’s residence halls.


RBI • Short Stop Deli  

This roast beef sandwich comes as a single, double, or grand slam.


Ithaca College Bombers • Hal's Delicatessen

An Ithaca institution since the 1960s, Hal’s has a sandwich named for that college on the other hill, but we chose to highlight this one, with corned beef, pastrami, cole slaw, turkey, and Russian dressing.