Distinguish Web pages from pages found on the Web.

When people speak of Web pages, they usually don't mean books and research articles, but books, government documents, research reports, and periodical articles are all accessible through the Web, and they can be quite different in scope, focus, and reliability than pages originally designed for the web. That makes it important for you to recognize what you are looking at.

No one controls what can be posted on the web, but research articles and other published materials have often gone through a rigorous review process.

What can be confusing is how publishing has been changing. Some research materials may only be available online. Many libraries no longer subscribe to the paper version of some periodicals, but subscribe instead to the online version of the journal or rely on full text access through Web-based periodical databases.

When teachers tell you they don't want you to use Web pages to do research, they don't mean (or shouldn't mean) you can't use the Web to do your research. Compare the results between a regular Google search and a search using Google Scholar.

The online version of a periodical article is no more or less reliable than the same article found in the print version of the journal. If you find a periodical article on the Web, however, you might not be able to easily see if it was orginally published in a magazine with a glossy cover that was filled with advertising or in a journal that is intended for an academic or professional audience. It can often take a bit of an effort to distinguish among magazines, trade journals, and peer reviewed journals.

Questions to think about:

Do you think this page was designed for the Web, or do you think it was originally something else? If it was originally something else, what something else was it?

And now for a quick review.

ICYouSee T is for Thinking
Ithaca College Library
Last modified: August 27, 2009