The Ithaca College chapter began in 1977 with a charter of ten members and now has a local membership of 61 faculty, administration and staff members and hundreds of on-campus student members.The following individuals have served as presidents of the Ithaca College chapter of Phi Kappa Phi:
- Shirley Hockett, 1977-1979
- John M. Bernard, 1979-1981
- John B. Harcourt, 1981-1983
- M. Raquib Zaman, 1983-1985
- Ronald R. Nicoson, 1985-1987
- Paul W. McBride, 1987-1989
- Marlene E. Barken, 1989-1991
- William B. Koch, 1991-1993
- Michael Twomey, 1993-1996
- John Keshishoglou, 1996-1998
- Wenmouth Williams, 1998-2000
- Nancy Rader, 2000-2003
- Hugh Rowland, 2003-2005
- Michael Twomey, 2005-2007
- Kim Dunnick, 2007-2009
- Michael Haaf, 2009-2011
- Bruce Henderson, 2011-2013
- Diane Birr, 2013-2015
- Hormoz Movassaghi, 2015-2017
- Deborah King, 2017-present
