News Story
Coming Out
Students reveal their sexual orientation to their parents
pam Arnold/The Ithacan
Senior Nora McCaffrey keeps a wall of photos to remind her of the good support system she has from friends.
“Get out of our school, you dyke!” yelled a large and intimidating
group of upperclassmen at senior Nora McCaffrey two months into
her freshman year of high school. They proceeded to corner her
into an empty classroom and slam her into a radiator, cracking a
rib and bruising her entire back.
But that wasn’t even the worst part for McCaffrey. The worst was
that she couldn’t seek comfort from her parents.
“I hadn’t come out to my parents yet,” she said. “I was terrified and
unsure. I was scared they weren’t going to accept me ever again.”
McCaffrey said she was afraid she was going to break her parents’
hearts with the news that she was gay.
“It’s very unhealthy to have a secret,” said McCaffrey, who never
reported the incident. “It eats away at you until you embrace it. I
had such an unhappy life. I just couldn’t be happy about
anything.”
Coming out is the process in which Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and
Transgender people inform other people about their sexual
orientation. There are many aspects to coming out that can be
difficult, but most agree that the hardest moment is telling their
parents.
Individuals confide in the first person at an average age of 16.
However, a majority of those 25 years old and under surveyed said
college is the best time, according to a recent study by OutProud!,
a national coalition for LGBT youth. Only 7 percent of the 6,872
individuals surveyed told their parents first. Those who haven’t yet
come out list the most common reason as fear of parents’
reactions.
Lisa Maurer, coordinator of the Center for LGBT Education,
Outreach and Services, said she helps students on a weekly basis
who are coming out to their parents.
“Coming to college, students obtain a sense of wanting to be
authentic and themselves,” Maurer said. “A secret will very often
wear and tear on their soul until it is released.”
In the summer before she left for Ithaca College, McCaffrey finally
sat her parents down and told them that she was lesbian. She said
her mom cried and was upset because she thought everything she
expected for her daughter in life was over. Her dad told McCaffrey
that he didn’t like labels.
After some time passed, McCaffrey and her parents established a
good relationship, and last year she comfortably brought home a
serious girlfriend.
“They realized that if I was strong enough to take what I did in high
school all alone, I could deal with hardships that may come later in
life,” she said. “It is my battle, and it’s very apparent that I can take
it.”
According to the American Psychological Association, the coming-
out process usually follows a general pattern. First, individuals will
tell other gay friends, then straight friends, then close family
members and then finally their parents.
When Kathy Ballard’s son, Adrian ’99, came out to her, she didn’t
have a clue that he was gay.
“I started crying and then so did he,” said Kathy Ballard, member of
the nonprofit organization Parents, Families and Friends of
Lesbians and Gays. “My husband just sat there, shocked.”
She said the hardest parts were knowing that her child was going
to deal with more issues than other children and all her
preconceived notions of his life may not come true.
“He told us that we could ask him any questions about
homosexuality,” Ballard said. “But I didn’t want to talk about it. I
just wanted it to go away.”
Adrian Ballard said he forced the topic on his parents, even when
they were uncomfortable.
“If you don’t talk about it, you’ll never come to terms with it,”
Adrian Ballard said. “It needs exposure.”
Kathy Ballard said after a couple of weeks of tears, she realized
they were all going to be OK and researched all she could on the
topic of homosexuality.
“There was no way I wasn’t going to love my child,” she said.
Adrian Ballard said when coming out, students should prepare for
the worst, but not expect the worst.
“Chances are that this thing about you won’t change their love,” he
said.
Some students, like freshman Heather Fields, who considers herself
“open but leaning lesbian,” have a hard time waiting for their
parents to accept their sexual orientation. Fields’ parents originally
didn’t tolerate the idea, and she said her home life was hard and
she considered moving out.
“At first I didn’t want to talk to my mom at all,” Fields said. “I
decided I didn’t like the person she was. I decided I didn’t have to
love her just because she was my mom.”
For many gay youth, the first signs that their emerging sexual
identity is unacceptable come from their own home, according to
the American Psychological Association. Kathy Ballard said she is
now amazed that her son had the courage to come out to her and
her husband. They attended a Baptist church that preached against
homosexuality, and her husband often told condescending gay
jokes at the dinner table.
“We realized that it was an extremely difficult thing to come out to
us, so he must have had no other choice,” she said. “He couldn’t
have done it to hurt us.”
Though most families work through the hardships of coming out,
some individuals aren’t as lucky. Sometimes LGBT students who
come out to their parents are kicked out of the house, cut off
financially or sent to counseling or camps to get “cured” of their
homosexuality.
Junior Aaron Escobedo came out as gay to his mother, but will not
tell his father, who Escobedo said has not played a big role in his
life, until he is financially secure.
“It’s a possibility that he would not be OK with me,” Escobedo said.
“At first, I thought, ‘Am I wrong to use my father for his money? Or
is it wrong of him to withhold my education just because I’m
gay?’”
More than 100 scholarships have been established for gay students
nationally to help with financial troubles that may be a
consequence of coming out, according to The Point Foundation,
one scholarship resource for LGBT students. The Astarea
Foundation has previously distributed grants to Ithaca College
students. Escobedo has received grants for three years from The
Alexander Foundation, a Colorado organization.
Many universities also offer individual awards to LGBT students.
George Washington University offers a $3,000 scholarship to a gay
student studying politics for a semester. Currently, Ithaca College
has no such scholarship, but Escobedo said alumni have contacted
the school willing to donate to such a fund. He said he hopes to
get organized soon and get the ball rolling.
“There’s no one saying, ‘Hey, we want you on our campus’ to LGBT
students right now,” Escobedo said. “I don’t see why we shouldn’t
start.”
Love in Action International is one of the most popular
organizations with programs designed to “address sexual
brokenness,” according to LIA’s Web site. The Rev. John Smid, the
executive director of Love in Action, said he used to practice
homosexual actions when he was young and then was “freed from
the myth” when he began studying the Bible, according to the Web
site.
In September, the Tennessee
Department of Mental Health and Developmental Disabilities
required the Memphis-based organization to obtain a license for
treating mentally ill clients. LIA is suing the state, claiming it is
violating its religious freedom, according to the Associated Press.
“Parents who kick out their children need to educate themselves,”
Kathy Ballard said. “Your child is not doing it to be cool or
different. It’s not a choice. People need to understand that.”
To avoid hardships as a result of coming out, Maurer suggested
two general guidelines.
“I suggest that you make sure the timing is good — try not to do it
during a big family holiday, don’t do it in the heat of anger to get
back at your parents and be sensitive of other issues in their lives
presently,” Maurer said. “It is also very important to
establish a support system beforehand, both financially and with
friends.”
Currently, there are more than 3,000 Gay Straight Alliance chapters
in all 50 states, according to The Advocate, a LGBT news magazine.
On campus, Ithaca College has prism, the educational and social
group which meets on Mondays, and Created Equal, which
implements projects to address problems facing LGBT people on
campus and nationally.