Now Is the Time for Hard Decisions

By Robin Roger, February 18, 2021
President Collado and Provost Cornish describe why strategic change is crucial now.

In an opinion piece published Feb. 18, Ithaca College President Shirley M. Collado and Provost La Jerne Terry Cornish explain why the enrollment-dependent business model is not sustainable for colleges, and how returning to “business as usual” after the COVID crisis passes would be a mistake.

“The time to activate needed change at Ithaca is now — even in the face of resistance,” they write.

The piece appeared in Inside Higher Ed, a website that features news and analysis of issues in higher education. In it, they describe the Academic Program Prioritization (APP) process and the “Shape of the College” document, which outlines plans to restructure the college’s program offerings, decreases the number of FTE (full-time equivalent) faculty members over the next three years, promotes equity among faculty, and encourages interdisciplinary opportunities for students. 

“That we are moving forward with this work at a time such as this reflects our commitment to the future of Ithaca and the success of our students. We must push forward because it is the right thing to do. Our students deserve nothing less.”

President Shirley M. Collado and Provost La Jerne Terry Cornish

“The document represents a major milestone for our college — and the latest milestone in an important and collaborative strategic planning process that began in 2018, when our community embarked on a yearlong effort to build a strategic plan, Ithaca Forever.”

One of the goals of the strategic plan was to determine and maintain an appropriate and sustainable size for IC’s programs and structures and the associated resources needed to do so. The goal is to establish a sustainable size of 5,000 students with a 12:1 student-to-faculty ratio, and it is tightly wedded to three key priorities: a commitment to academic excellence, a focus on creating a high-quality student experience and the intention to become an employer of choice.

They describe the APP process as an “iterative, participatory and data-driven program review, identifying areas of consolidation, reorganization, elimination and growth.”

“Implementing an academic program review process is necessary, realistic and extremely unpopular work that many institutions fail to undertake, except in times of crisis,” they write. “But the truth is that program prioritization should be ongoing — part of a continuous assessment process that ensures the vibrancy of the curriculum, encourages innovation and provides opportunities for strategic growth in academic programs at the undergraduate and graduate level by discontinuing programs that are under-enrolled or lack student demand.”

While acknowledging that Ithaca College has had to furlough staff, they point out that, historically, institutions have taken that easier path in times of financial uncertainty and organizational change.

“Not only does this fail to solve the underlying issues around the higher ed business model, but it also contributes to and sustains a deeply inequitable paradigm of employment in higher education that frames staff jobs as expendable yet faculty jobs as untouchable. For healthy, holistic and equitable transformation to occur, this paradigm must shift.”

They note that the coming years will be difficult for Ithaca College and for all of higher education, which is in deep need of systemic change, but that the future can look bright, with courageous, student-centered leadership.

“That we are moving forward with this work at a time such as this reflects our commitment to the future of Ithaca and the success of our students,” they write. “We must push forward because it is the right thing to do. Our students deserve nothing less.”

Read the Full Article on Inside Higher Ed