ICQ » 2006/2 »

New ICView Site

Back issues

About us

Contact us


Giving to


Ithaca College Home

Battle Continues


Thank you, Michael Battle (cover story, ICQ 2005/4).


It is no surprise that some disagree with the policies and practices of some U.S. administrations, including the current. 


I certainly do not agree with all, and some (previous inaction, the USS Cole, the Khobar Towers, etc.) have actually led to the current situation in Iraq. Who was the president then? How many times do you let someone slap you in the face?


But slamming Mike Battle (“MailBox” letter from Margaret Lacey O’Leary ’69 in the ICQ 2006/1 issue) for his support of the president (his boss) and for the job he has done over the years in support of the local and federal laws? Give me a break! Implying that Mike and others are criminals only provides support to those that would like to tear this country apart.


T. H. Butler Smythe ’77

Lt. Commander, U.S. Navy, retired

Solomons, Maryland

More Harcourt Memories


Professor John Harcourt did nothing less than turn my life around. And he did it in only five minutes.


I remember taking my seat on the first day of his Shakespeare class. I was not looking forward to grinding my way through six plays, but it was a required class and I was a sophomore transfer coming from a very shaky freshman year.


Both wiry and wired, Professor Harcourt took his place and quieted the room down simply by waiting. He then turned everything upside down by announcing that the quiz for each play would precede the discussion.


Did I hear that right?


The professor explained that this approach helped make sure everyone was ready to engage in the discussions to follow. After all, the discussion was the important part—we were here to discuss Shakespeare, not take quizzes!


I panicked. I might actually have to read something!


With dead-on instinct, the good professor then spoke directly to my fears. He compared reading Shakespeare to reading screenplays; reading is a far cry from the experience of seeing the play or the film itself. Fortunately, he said, the library had recordings of performances of the plays we would be studying, and encouraged us to read along.


A scholar was born.


The “A” I received in his class went a long way toward helping me make dean’s list that semester. And I went on to repeat his class in my junior and senior years (the plays changed each time), and I took a spring Shakespeare seminar to boot.


Thank you, Professor Harcourt!


Andrew Dugas ’84

Fairfax, California

The ICQ is published for alumni, parents of current students, faculty, administrators, staff, retirees, friends, and neighbors of Ithaca College. Its mission is to offer a candid, accurate, thoughtful, and lively view of College events and people and to stimulate discussion of issues of interest to the College community and the wider readership. We welcome letters on subjects covered in the magazine and of broad interest to our readers, as long as they are respectful and not insulting to any person or group. We publish as many in the print version as we can, subject to space limitations. Overflow letters can be found here at the ICQ Online. We edit for space, clarity, and style. Send your letters by post to Editor, ICQ, 231 Alumni Hall, Ithaca College, Ithaca NY 14850 USA or via e-mail to editor [at] ithaca.edu (replace the [at] with @). Or fill out the form at left under "Contact Us."

previous page:
Shaping a Life
next page:
Reclaiming Part of a Lost Homeland