2021-2022 Season
- House of Desires
- Rent
- The Other Shore
- We Wear the Sea Like a Coat
- Red Bike
- Fun Home
- One Act Play Festival (Lily's Purple Plastic Purse, Unicorn Girl, Free Play)
2020-2021 Season
- She Kills Monsters (streamed)
- Sweeney Todd (cancelled because of Covid-19)
- Gather Ye Children! (streamed)
- Shifting Spaces (streamed)
- Trojan Women (streamed)
- Head Over Heals (streamed)
- The Magic Flute (streamed)
- Stop Kiss (streamed)
2019-2020 Season
- Everybody
- Sister Act
- The Antigone Project
- Dido and Aeneas
- Pippin (cancelled because of Covid-19)
- Marie Antoinette (cancelled because of Covid-19)
2018-2019 Season
- Twelfth Night
- Ragtime
- Experiential Atonement
- The Old Maid and the Thief and The Medium
- Violet
- Marisol
2017-2018 Season
- Angels in America, Part One: Millenium Approaches
- Wonderful Town
- In the Red and Brown Water
- Cendrillon
- Sense and Sensibility
- Cabaret
2016-2017 Season
- Blood Wedding
- Company
- Winter Bodies
- La Clemenza di Tito
- The Cradle Will Rock
- The Rover
2015-2016 Season
- As You Like It
- A Chorus Line
- Anon(ymous)
- Semele
- Dogfight
- Arcadia
2014-2015 Season
- The Good Person of Setzuan
- How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying
- Anna in the Tropics
- Little Women: The Opera
- Dance: Flight of the Heart
- You Can't Take It With You
2013-2014 Season
- Fires in the Mirror
- Into the Woods
- Mere Mortals
- L'etoile
- Gone Missing
- The Crucible
2012-2013 Season
- Man From Nebraska
- Legally Blonde
- Translations
- Suor Angelica & Gianni Schicchi
- Spring Awakening
- An Enemy of the People
2011-2012 Season
- Plumfield, Iraq
- The Light in the Piazza
- Illuminated Bodies
- The Magic Flute
- Working
- Measure for Measure
2010-2011 Season
- Electra
- Chicago
- How I Learned To Drive
- L'Orfeo
- Coram Boy
- Baby
2009-2010 Season
- Top Girls
- Children of Eden
- Eurydice
- The Little Prince
- Floyd Collins
- Much Ado About Nothing
2008-2009 Season
- Metamorphoses
- The Wild Party
- The Exonerated
- Cendrillon & L'Enfant et Les Sortileges
- A New Brain
- Tartuffe
2007-2008 Season
- Hedda Gabler
- The Full Monty
- The Last Night of Ballyhoo
- La Finta Giardiniera
- Dance: No Translation Needed
- A Midsummer Night's Dream
2006-2007 Season
- Etta Jenks
- Urinetown, The Musical
- The Seagull
- Acis and Galatea
- 36 Views
- The Count of Monte Cristo
2005-2006 Season
- Burn This
- Grease
- Dancing at Lughnasa
- The Merry Widow
- Violet
- Twelfth Night
2004-2005 Season
- Les Liaisons Dangereuses
- Seussical: The Musical
- The Shape of Things
- The Consul
- Owl Creek
- Our Country's Good
2003-2004 Season
- The Waiting Room
- The Mystery of Edwin Drood
- Pericles
- Cosi fan tutte
- Yentl
- Dancing the Journey
2002-2003 Season
- The Laramie Project
- The Threepenny Opera
- November Girls
- Die Fledermaus
- Bat Boy: The Musical
- The Importance of Being Earnest
2001-2002 Season
- Romeo and Juliet
- Parade
- A Voice of My Own
- Three Operas: The Impressario, A Hand of Bridge, Riders to the Sea
- The World Goes 'Round
- The Colored Museum
- The Cherry Orchard
2000-2001 Season
- Goodnight, Desdemona (Good Morning, Juliet)
- A Little Night Music
- Lily Dale
- L'incoronazione di Poppea (The Coronation of Poppea)
- Side Show
- The Trojan Women